Box Breathing Came in Dead Last. Here's What Actually Won.
Man, everybody loves box breathing. Navy SEALs use it. Therapists teach it. It's probably the first breathing technique most people ever try. So when researchers finally put it head to head with a few other techniques, I had to see how it did.
Rather watch? Here's the quick version:
It came in dead last.
The study
Joshua Marchant and his team at Brigham Young University published this in 2025 in Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback. 84 college students tried four breathing techniques while hooked up to heart and CO2 sensors:
Box breathing (in 4, hold 4, out 4, hold 4)
4-7-8 breathing (in 4, hold 7, out 8)
Slow breathing at 6 breaths a minute, in for 4, out for 6
Slow breathing at 6 breaths a minute, in for 5, out for 5
They measured heart rate variability, which is your body's calm-and-recover signal. Higher HRV generally means your nervous system can shift gears and settle down.
The key numbers
Both versions of 6 breaths a minute boosted HRV more than box breathing or 4-7-8. The researchers called it a small to medium effect. In for 4, out for 6 came out on top, in for 5, out for 5 was right behind it, then 4-7-8. Box breathing came in dead last.

No holds, no counting gymnastics. Just a smooth in and a smooth out.
The part nobody talks about
Here's what's wild. Box breathing and 4-7-8 are actually slower. Box breathing at 4-4-4-4 works out to under 4 breaths a minute. 4-7-8 is even slower. On paper, they should have won if slower was always better.
They didn't. The holds aren't the magic. A smooth, steady rhythm is.

And one more surprise: the 6-a-minute groups actually dropped their CO2 a little, which means people were over-breathing slightly. So it's not just slow. It's slow and light.
The fine print
This was one session. Breathwork is a practice, and one sitting doesn't tell you what happens after weeks of training.
These were college students, not my usual guys over 40.
None of the four techniques changed mood or blood pressure in that single session.
Box breathing isn't bad. It just didn't win on HRV here.
How I use this
This is the same slow, steady rhythm I teach my clients for calming down during the day. Here's the simple version:
Breathe in for 4 seconds. Gentle and quiet.
Breathe out for 6 seconds. Slow and relaxed, no hold.
Keep it going for 5 minutes. Light breaths, not big ones.

Just a little bit of a caution: if you feel dizzy or tingly, you're breathing too big. Make each breath smaller and lighter. And never do breath holds or fast breathing in water.
Want to go deeper?
Grab my first course, Airway to Heaven, free at change-u.com. Or if you want help building a breathing practice that actually fits your life, book a free call with me.
Breathe easy, my friends.
Miles
Study: Marchant, J. (2025). Comparing the Effects of Square, 4-7-8, and 6 Breaths-per-Minute Breathing Conditions on Heart Rate Variability, CO2 Levels, and Mood. Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback.









Comments